In 2024, De SpiegelOnderzoek, in collaboration with the Municipality of Nijmegen and partner organisation OpenEmbassy, studied the experiences of civic integration participants under the new Civic Integration Act 2021. The aim was to identify bottlenecks and success factors in the integration pathway and to formulate targeted recommendations to improve the municipal offer.
De SpiegelOnderzoek was responsible for the quantitative part of the study. Through a questionnaire among 149 participants in the municipality of Nijmegen (refugee status holders and family migrants), their experiences with the integration pathway were mapped.
Key results
- The integration programme is generally rated neutral to positive; refugee status holders are more positive than family migrants.
- Case managers play a key role, but the perceived quality, availability and continuity of support vary widely.
- The Broad Intake and the personal integration plan (PIP) provide structure, but do not always match participants’ needs, particularly for women.
- Labour market participation is often insecure and only partly matches education and experience; better routes into work are needed.
- Positive experiences with municipal support are linked to better social participation and mental wellbeing; language barriers and waiting times are obstacles.
Our recommendations
- Invest from the start in a strong relationship of trust through the case manager, and provide clear information.
- Safeguard the availability and continuity of case managers, for example through an additional point of contact.
- Make language provision more flexible and easier to combine with work and family, with room for tailoring and adjusting the intensity.
- Strengthen the link between language, work and talent development, including access to higher language levels.
- Increase opportunities for social participation by offering more chances to practise Dutch in everyday life.
The results were brought together in an integrated report and used as input for the Municipality of Nijmegen’s Asylum & Integration policy framework and implementation programme. The study underlines the importance of structurally involving the experiences of participants in policy development and evaluation.


